Communication
Why you keep having the same fight (and how to stop)
The topics may change—money, household responsibilities, family, or how you spend time together—but the arguments can feel remarkably familiar. One partner raises a concern, the other becomes defensive or withdraws, and the first may respond by pushing harder. Before long, both feel hurt, misunderstood, or disconnected. Although the details vary from couple to couple, these recurring patterns can become difficult to interrupt.
It is usually a cycle, not a topic
The issues couples disagree about are often important, but the way they respond to one another can become just as significant as the disagreement itself. One partner may pursue a conversation while the other withdraws; one may criticize while the other becomes defensive. Each is reacting to the other, often without recognizing how their responses contribute to a recurring cycle. Over time, both may feel increasingly misunderstood and disconnected.
Recognizing this pattern can help couples begin to see the difficulty as something happening between them, rather than something inherently wrong with either partner.
What is underneath
Beneath anger, criticism, defensiveness, or withdrawal, there are often more vulnerable emotions that are difficult to recognize and express. One partner may feel lonely, unimportant, or afraid of losing connection. The other may feel inadequate, overwhelmed, or fearful of disappointing their partner. Sometimes both are experiencing similar fears but expressing them in very different ways.
When these underlying feelings remain unspoken, partners may respond primarily to one another’s protective reactions rather than understanding what each is actually experiencing. Helping couples recognize, experience, and communicate these more vulnerable emotions is an important part of my work.
Three things to try
- Recognize the pattern rather than blaming each other. Saying “I think we’re getting caught in that same pattern again” can create an opportunity to pause and approach the disagreement differently.
- Take a break when emotions become overwhelming. When either partner is too upset to listen or respond constructively, taking time to settle can be helpful. Agree on when to return to the conversation so that the break doesn’t become another form of withdrawal.
- Try expressing the feeling beneath the reaction. “I felt really alone last night” may invite a different response than “You were on your phone all night.” Sharing the more vulnerable feeling can help your partner understand what is happening for you.
When it is hard to do alone
Recognizing a recurring pattern is one thing; changing it can be much more difficult, particularly when emotions are intense and both partners feel misunderstood.
In couples therapy, I help partners recognize the patterns that keep them disconnected and better understand the emotional experiences underlying their reactions. An important part of this work involves helping each person access and express those feelings while supporting the other in hearing and understanding them.
My approach is informed by Emotionally Focused Therapy, along with elements of the Gottman Method, Imago dialogue, and my experience in mediation. Rather than following a rigid formula, I draw on these approaches in response to what each couple needs as our work unfolds.
Read more about communication and conflict, or schedule a free consultation.
Next step
Thinking about talking to someone?
A free 15-minute phone or video conversation is a low-pressure way to see whether working together feels right. Online individual and couples therapy for people in New Hampshire and Massachusetts. Individual sessions are $150 and couples sessions are $180.
Request a free consultation